Chapter One

If there was one thing Claire knew about her father, Aran Rey, it was that he always forgave her. But when she looked down at the letters she held in her hands she was worried she’d gone too far this time.

The morning light bounced off the harbour five floors below her apartment and sent ripples of gold across the white walls in her bedroom. In one hand she held a letter from Sydney University and in the other, one from the bank. Even though both held bad news, Claire didn’t care. Being in debt had never worried her and now it was official that she couldn’t go back to law school, she was relieved.

Claire did care how her father would take it, though. She’d had the letters for a month but couldn’t bring herself to tell him. It was the fourth letter from the bank, and the fact that this one had a red header with a warning label told her she needed to let him know soon, or they’d phone him anyway since he was her guarantor.

It wasn’t that she didn’t want to tell him, it was that she didn’t want him to get depressed. The memory of his last episode made her wary of upsetting him. Why couldn’t he just accept she didn’t want to be a lawyer and pay her bill?

Even though she’d had this conversation with herself for the past few weeks, the talk with Aran would have to wait one more day. She shoved the letters under the alarm clock on her bedside table. It was Friday and she had plans.

She caught her long wavy hair and clipped it to the back of her head. Saturday was a good day to break bad news, she told herself, and he was usually in a good mood on a Saturday morning. She pictured him reading The Saturday Paper with coffee and a croissant on the terrace, looking up now and then to watch the Sydney ferries criss-cross the harbour.

Claire opened the door to her dressing room and walked through to the ensuite. She bent towards the mirror and ran coral coloured lipstick around her lips. She mashed them together and drew a black line under her eyelid, then flicked her lashes with some mascara. She stepped back to look at herself; jeans, black bra, a white singlet and aqua resin bangles. Appropriate for meeting the old men fishing from Rozelle wharf today.

She’d been talking to them on and off for a couple of weeks before she asked if she could take their photos. This was her sixth wharf around the harbour. She might do rock fishermen next and then the fishing boat. Just because she hadn’t attended her university classes, didn’t mean she’d been doing nothing for the last nine months. She was sure her father would be surprised at how good her photos were. He did, eventually, approve of everything she did. He wouldn’t feel so bad about her Uni results once he knew she’d been invited to show her work in the Sydney Photographic competition.

On the way through the wardrobe, she reached up and pulled her camera bag from the shelf. She loved that bag with her beautiful Leica camera surrounded by little compartments. It reminded her of the doll house she’d had when she was a child. If it wasn’t for those letters, it would feel like the beginning of a good day.

She knew she should catch the early morning light and picked up her portfolio, sniffed the soft leather and slipped it into her orange tote bag. She wanted to show her best friend, Gemma, when they met later in the day. She pulled on her cap and grabbed her keys.

Her father was sitting in an arm chair when she walked into her living room. Claire was startled, he never came into her quarters.

He was dressed like he’d been for a run, and when she looked closer she saw patches of sweat on his t-shirt. She could tell by the way he pulled on his lip with his front teeth that he was angry. He bent forward, put a letter on the coffee table and pushed it towards her. It was a twin of one under her alarm clock.

‘You know Claire. I’ve done the wrong thing by you.’ His voice was too calm and she knew he knew.

‘That’s a bit lame dad.’

‘And being a 26-year-old woman who lies to her father is not lame?’

She kept her voice light and even. ‘You shouldn’t open my mail. Can we talk about this later, I have an appointment?’

The glassy hardness in his green eyes unnerved her.

‘I can explain.’

‘I wish you would,’ he said.

She exhaled. This wasn’t how she imagined breaking the news, and looking at him tapping his foot against the side of the coffee table, she wasn’t sure of the tone she should take. Usually, when she was lax with time or responsibilities she could cajole him till he shook his head and walked away. Sometimes he seemed to admire her breaking the rules. This didn’t seem like one of those times. She’d never lied to him for such an extended length before. Nine months was a long time.

‘I’m still waiting, Claire.’

In her defence, all she could think of was her photographs. She pulled her portfolio from her bag and handed it to him. If he liked the pictures, then she might have a chance.

She leant towards him and turned the first page. ‘That’s what I want to do, take photos.’

Her large photo of a man in his 70’s fishing from a wharf was on the first page. The light hitting his face revealed deep grooves in his skin that ran from his temple to his mouth. His eye looked as silver as the fish in the bucket at his feet. She flicked the page to another old man with a cigarette in the corner of his mouth and a faraway look in his eye, dangling a line into the water. She went to turn the page again but he snapped the book shut. She could almost hear his heart thumping in his chest.

‘You’re kidding me, right. You’ve wasted your time taking pictures of other people wasting their time fishing!’

The portfolio looked insignificant in his hand.

‘Dad, I’ve had four photos accepted in an emerging talent competition. That’s not an easy thing to do.’

He stood up abruptly and paced the floor. He made the room seem hotter, stirring up the air as he moved. ‘So, when I dropped you off at the gates of the law school – what was it, two or three times a week – where did you go?’

She tried to sound casual but realised it was time to tell him. ‘Okay, I know it looks bad but I never wanted to be a lawyer.’

It was true. She’d only suggested she went there because she thought it would make him happy and God knows at the time he needed cheering up. He’d just split up from his latest girlfriend, Kate. Not the first of his girlfriends to leave because he wouldn’t move in with them. He’d refused and Kate left.

He raised his voice, he sounded bewildered. ‘You never wanted to? You got me to agree to pay for law school and agree to support you, again. You don’t need a law degree or any degree to work, you just need to work and that’s clearly where I’ve failed.’

She looked at her father and pushed aside the thought that he might be right. ‘Come on, at the time you liked the idea.’

‘But that’s what it was, just an idea, like all your ideas. They don’t come to much, do they? Except for the costs involved.’

He was right, she often left things unfinished. But the photography had been her idea and she’d planned the shoots, taken the photos, decided on the best ones and applied to the emerging photographers’ exhibition. She’d even talked her way on to a tuna boat for a week to document the trip. Now she was sorry she hadn’t involved him in the project earlier. Maybe then he would understand how much she’d achieved.

She handed him back the portfolio and spoke quickly so he couldn’t interrupt. ‘Dad, please just look at this book again, they’re good. I know I should’ve told you. I’ve got more planned along the same themes, rock fishermen and a week on a long line tuna boat. Thinking about calling it something like The Sea Claims Them. Is that too lame?’

He gripped the portfolio. She heard his breath quicken and his skin seemed to turn white. She stepped towards him and put her hand on his arm to steady him. He pulled away and his face crumpled in what she could only describe as deep pain.

‘You are not going on a fishing boat.’

Claire didn’t want to hurt her father but she was an adult and he was overreacting. ‘That’s not really your call.’

For a moment Claire thought he was going to slap her. He’d never hit anyone in his life, as far as she knew, but there was a wild look in his eye.

Instead he slammed the portfolio on the table. The leather on wood made a loud crack. ‘You are going to stop right now. Do you hear me? This is a complete waste of time.’

It was weird, thought Claire, how he was prepared to believe her when she made things up but wouldn’t listen now that it was real.

‘I love it. Photography makes me feel alive, like I could work till 2am in the morning just getting everything right, then get up at dawn to start all over again. Just like you do, it’s the first time I’ve ever felt like this about anything.’

He turned his back. She thought she’d cracked through his disappointment until he spoke again.

‘You sound really convincing. I guess your mother’s right; I shouldn’t believe a word you say.’

The thought that he’d discussed her situation with her mother made her grind her teeth. Ever since Ruth had chosen to move in with her female lover, Pat, when Claire was a teenager, Claire made the rules where her mother was concerned.

‘Well, I had a really good teacher then, didn’t I?’

‘That’s out of order, Claire.’

She never really understood why he stood up for her mother. After all, she’d left him, too. But Ruth still had a lot of influence in his life.

‘What else did she say?’ she asked.

‘You’d make a good con woman. And I think she’s right.’

It had been their father-daughter joke since she was a kid; almost a term of affection between them to call her a con woman. He always seemed proud of her determination. Maybe this was a point where forgiveness could be unlocked from his usually soft heart.

She smiled. ‘A benign one, remember?’

His shoulders dropped and he closed his eyes. She’d grown up used to watching his moods, calculating how far to push, when to retreat. Watching the balance tip one way or the other till she got her own way. She wanted to win but didn’t want to see him lose his spark. That was a bad sign. How long was it after Kate left that he came right? Three months. Three months of living with a zombie, some days she felt like she couldn’t leave him alone.

‘This isn’t benign, Claire. This is you being dishonest.’

He’d never accused of her that before. It was like a door slammed in her face.

‘I’m sorry, I’m sorry. I was going to tell you about the letters, dad, tomorrow, honest.’

As soon as she said it, she knew she’d just shot herself in the foot. He had only mentioned one letter.

‘Letters, plural?’ He held up the letter from Sydney Uni and shook his head. ‘I only have one.’

Claire flicked her eyes from side-to-side. She wondered how she could avoid mentioning the bank. He must have seen the thought pass across her face because he yelled at her. ‘Don’t even think about it.’

At least his spark was back. She cleared her throat. ‘I maxed out my credit card.’

‘Oh for… how much cash do I give you a week?’

She hung her head and wished she’d left the house before dawn. ‘You know how much.’

‘I want to hear you say it.’

She whispered, ‘$400.’

‘You spend your weekly allowance and get into debt over god knows what. How much did that camera cost?’ He pointed to her camera bag.

‘Seven, seven thousand dollars with the lenses, but I got it on special.’

‘Well you can put it on eBay, that’ll be a start.’

‘There’s no way,’ Claire started… ‘No, I am not selling my camera.’

He walked to her front door and opened it. The flowers on the hall table in the foyer looked fresh, very different from the mood in her room. He bounced his fist against the door and looked just above her head when he spoke.

‘If you want to live here, these are your options. You come to work with me or get a job, today, next week. I can’t keep making life easy for you. It’s not good for you in the long run, I see that now. Your credit cards are gone and so is your allowance. I expect rent within a month. Do you understand?’

He lowered his gaze to look her directly in the eye, ‘You are grounded as of now. If you leave this house before you get a job I will change the access code to the front door and your quarters. Is that clear?’

She watched him shut the door, as it clicked the sound of a text message arriving interrupted her thoughts. She fished blindly at the bottom of her orange tote bag and found her phone. It was warm when she touched it. The message was from her ex-boyfriend.

‘Wanted you to hear from me first, Bethany and I are moving in together this week, Marcus.’

For God’s sake, they’d only split up a month ago. The problem with Marcus was he wanted much more than she wanted to give. It was a shame because she liked him a lot.

Claire smiled. In some ways, she was exactly like her father. He would never commit either. But, unlike him, she made sure she never got down about the things that went wrong in her life. Recover quickly and move on was her philosophy.

And as for Aran, it was obvious that Ruth had coached him. He never said ‘grounded’. Pure Ruth, thinking she could ground a 26- year-old.

If Claire did what her father expected, she’d end up working in some city office, punching data or looking after a psycho manager. She couldn’t do it. On the other hand, if she didn’t and he went down-hill then she’d be stuck looking after him.

Claire looked around her apartment. She loved living here. It had everything she could ever want, four big rooms with all her furniture, a kitchen, and a long deep balcony to take in the panoramic views. She was separated from the main penthouse by her own front door, so Aran was close. But not too close.

Marcus’ text was still live in her hand. It was time to put her philosophy to work and move on. Bethany could have Marcus. She deleted the text.

She wasn’t changing tack now, not when she was so close to having everything she wanted. Aran would get over his disappointment, and if he didn’t, Ruth could look after him this time. She owed her daughter at least that much. Claire picked up her bags and left the apartment.

She knew Aran would never change the access codes.

Double Lives -

Please send me the next & other upcoming courses dates.
(If you have other questions – please use the form on the Contact Us page.)

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google  Privacy Policy  and  Terms of Service apply.

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE COURSE UPDATES, WRITING TIPS AND SPECIAL OFFERS CLICK HERE

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google  Privacy Policy  and  Terms of Service apply.